MHC Ch. 9: Psychoanalytic, Adlerian, and Humanistic Theories of Counseling

4 Variables that determine the amount of growth and change in any type of counseling

1. Counselor
2. Client
3. Setting
4. Theoretical orientation

Theory

A model that counselors use as a guide to hypothesize about the formation of possible solutions to a problem.

5 Requirements of Good Theory

1. Clear, easily understood, and communicable
2. Comprehensive
3. Explicit (you can test it) and heuristic
4. Specific in relating means to desired outcomes
5. Useful to its intended practitioners

6 Functions of Theory (help counselor in a practical way)

1. Theory helps counselors find unity and relatedness within the diversity of existence
2. Theory compels counselors to examine relationship they would otherwise overlook
3. Theory gives counselors operational guidelines by which to work and helps them ev

Eclectic

The majority of counselors (60-70%) identify themselves as this. They use various techniques and theories to match their clients' needs.

McBride & Martin: Hierarchy of Eclectic Practices

1. Syncretism
2. Traditional
3. Theoretical integrationism

Syncretism

-1st level of eclecticism
-Sloppy, unsystematic process of putting unrelated clinical concepts together.

Traditional

-2nd level of eclecticism
-Combines compatible features from diverse sources more thoughtfully than syncretism and in greater depth.

Theoretical integrationism

-3rd level of eclecticism
-Requires counselors to master at least two theories before making any combination.

Technical eclecticism

-4th level of eclecticism
-The idea that techniques rather than theories are used to treat clients.
-Includes Lazarus's (2008) BASIC ID

Lazarus's BASIC ID

Behavior
Affect
Sensations
Imagery
Cognition
Interpersonal relationships
Drugs

Transtheoretical Model (TTM)

-5th (final) level of eclecticism
-Developmentally based and direction-focused and purposes 5 levels of change.

5 Levels of Change in TTM

-Symptom/situation problems
-Maladaptive cognitions
-Current interpersonal conflicts
-Family system conflicts
-Intrapersonal conflicts

Counseling from a TTM perspective allows for:

-A macroscopic approach
-Person adaptaion

Macroscopic approach

involving a broad and comprehensive theoretical framework

Personal adaptation

involving an increase in critical, logical, accurate, and scientific-like thinking

Psychoanalytic Theories

-Among first type of counseling to gain public recognition and acceptance
-Freud credited with development

Psychoanalysis: Founders and Developers

Sigmund Freud, Anna Freud, Heinz Kohut

Sigmund Freud

Viennese psychiatrist primarily associated with psychoanalysis.

Anna Freud

Daughter of Sigmund Freud, elaborated the theory with application to children and the development of defense mechanisms

Heinz Kohut

Extended the theory to developmental issues, especially attachment, through conceptualization of object-relations theory

Psychoanalysis: View of Human Nature

People have a:
-Conscious mind
-Preconscious mind
-Unconscious mind

Conscious mind

attuned to awareness of outside world

Preconscious mind

hidden memories or forgotten experiences that can be remembered

Unconscious mind

the instinctual, repressed, and powerful forces

Id

Psychoanalysis - Freud
-amoral basic instincs
-operates on the pleasure principle

Ego

Psychoanalysis - Freud
-conscious
-decision-making "executive of the mind"
-operates on reality principle

Superego

Psychoanalysis - Freud
-conscience of the mind that contains values of parental figures
-operates on moral principle

Oral stage

mouth is the chief pleasure zone

Anal stage

delight is in withholding or eliminating feces

Phallic stage

chief zone of pleasure is in sex organs; individuals must work through sexual desires

Latency

energy focused on peer activities and personal mastery of cognitive learning and physical skills

Genital stage

if previous stages have gone well, each gender takes more interest in the other and normal heterosexual patterns of interaction appear

Fixation

a person's development is arrested at a particular stage

Defense mechanisms

ways of coping with anxiety on unconscious level by denying or distorting reality.

Defense mechanisms (list of)

-Repression
-Denial
-Regression
-Projection
-Rationalization
-Reaction Formation
-Displacement

Psychoanalysis: Techniques

-Free Association
-Dream analysis
-Analysis of transference
-Analysis of resistance
-Interpretation

Free Association

the client says whatever comes to mind

Dream analysis

clients are encouraged to dream and remember dreams and the analyst helps interpret

Analysis of Transference

analyst encourages transference and interprets positive or negative feelings expressed

Analysis of Resistance

can help clients gain insight in their resisting and other behaviors

Interpretation

the counselor helps the client understand meaning of past and present personal events

Alfred Adler (Adlerian Theory)

-founder of Individual Psychology
-emphasized the holistic and indivisible nature of people

Adlerian theory

-focus on social interest and purposefulness of behavior
-importance of developing a healthy style of life
-internationally popular

Adlerian theory: View of Human Nature

People are primarily motivated by social interest - a feeling of being connected to society as part of the social whole

Striving for perfection

Adlerian
a process in which people strive to become successful

Inferiority complex

Adlerian
a tendency for people to feel inferior to others becomes a complex when feelings are not worked through

Superiority complex

Adlerian
developed when a person overcompensates for feelings of inferiority

Style of life

Adlerian
-an individual's methods of relating to others
-viewing the world
-governing behavior

Adlerian technique

-Confrontation
-Asking "the question"
-Encouragement
-Acting "as if

Confrontation

the counselor challenges the client to consider their own private logic

Asking "the question

What would be different if you were well?

Encouragement

counselors encourage clients to feel good about selves and others

Acting "as if

clients act as if they are the person they want to be

Spitting in the client's soup

counselor points out behaviors to a client and ruins the payoff for the behavior

Catching oneself

clients learn to become aware of self-destructive behaviors or thoughts

Task setting

clients set short range, attainable goals and eventually work up to long-term, realistic objectives

Push button

clients encouraged to realize they have choices about what stimuli in their lives they pay attention to

Humanistic theories

-Person-centered counseling
-Existential counseling
-Gestalt therapy

Person-centered counseling

Founded by Carl Rogers and described in his book "Counseling and Psychotherapy

PCC: View of Human Nature

Phenomenological perspective
Self Theory
Positive regard

Phenomenological perspective

what is important in the person's view of reality rather than the event itself

Self-theory

the self is an outgrowth of the person's experience

Positive regard

love, warmth, care, respect are needed for a healthy self to emerge

PCC Techniques

3 Necessary Conditions of Counseling
-Empathy
-Unconditional Positive Regard
-Congruence
*The quality of the counseling relationship is much more important that techniques.

Motivational Interviewing

-grew out of person-centered approach
-helps ambivalent clients assess their thought and feelings as they being making changes

Existential Counseling Founders

Rollo May - focused on anxiety with regard to life and death
Viktor Frankl - focused on finding meaning in life even under extremely negative conditions

Existential: View of Human Nature

-People for their lives by the choices they make
-Logotherapy

Logotherapy

meaning goes beyond self-actualization and exists at 3 levels
-Ultimate meanings
-Meaning of the moment
-Common day-to-day meaning

Existential counselors

concentrate on being authentic with their clients and entering deep personal relationships with them

Existential techniques

-Does not limit counselors to specific techniques
-Most powerful technique is the relationship counselors have with their clients
-Existential counselors borrow some techniques from other models of counseling such as:
1. awareness exercises
2. imagery
3.

Gestalt Therapy

Gestalt means "whole figure"
Founded by Frederick "Fritz" Perls

Gestalt: View of Human Nature

-Self-actualization
-Antideterministic view
-Unfinished business

Self-actualization

is centered in the present

Antideterministic view

each person is able to change and become responsible

Unfinished business

earlier thoughts, feelings, and reactions that still affect a person's functioning and ability to live life in the present

Gestalt techniques

Exercises - ready-made techniques, i.e. enactment of fantasies, role-playing, psychodrama
Experiments - unplanned activities that grow out of the interaction between counselor and client

Dream work

Gestalt
Dreams are messages that represent a person's place at a certain time.

The empty chair

Gestalt
Clients talk to different parts of their personality with the chair as the focus

Making the rounds

Gestalt
Used in group settings; a theme or feeling expressed by a client should be faced by every person in the group

I take responsibility

make statements about perceptions and close with the phrase "I take responsibility for it.

Exaggeration

clients accentuate unwitting movements or gestures

May I feed you a sentence?

counselor asks whether or not client will certain sentence that makes the client's thoughts explicit