Chapter 4: Ethics Theories and Approaches: Conceptual Tools for Ethical Decision Making

clinical reasoning

the complex thought process that health professionals use during therapeutic interactions

ethical reasoning

a mode of clinical reasoning used to recognize, analyze, and clarify ethical problems that arise; helps clinicians make decisions regarding the right thing to do in a particular case; the focus is not on what COULD be done for the patient, rather on what SHOULD be done

ethical theory

a theory that is researched and well-developed and provides us with an assumption about the very nature of doing right and wrong

ethical approach

does not propose to be a complete system of model but an aid to exiting ethical theories

normative ethics

the study of ethical action; it is the branch of philosophical ethics that investigates the set of questions that arise when considering how one ought to act, morally speaking

metaethics

a branch of analytic philosophy that explores the status, foundations, and scope of moral values, properties, and words; whereas the fields of applied ethics and normative theory focus on what is moral, this focuses on what morality itself isBook def: tries to discover the nature and meaning of ethical reasons we propose as valid for making judgements about morality

story or case approach

ethical approach that assumes that morally relevant information is embedded in the story

foundationalist based

(in Epistemology) a belief that is justified based on basic or foundational beliefs

narrative approaches

ethical approach based on the observation that humans become a part of a community through the hearing and telling of stories; concludes that good moral judgment lies on the analysis and understanding of narratives

postmodernists

assert that because there are radical differences among people and cultures, according to gender, age, ethnicity, or other differences, no one set of moral rules or values is a valid guide "across the board" or even "across a relationship"Postmodern sociology can be said to focus on conditions of life which became increasingly prevalent in the late 20th century in the most industrialized nations, including the ubiquity of mass media and mass production, the rise of a global economy and a shift from manufacturing to service economies.

ethics of care approach

ethics approach that has as its major question: "What is required of a health professional to be best able to express, 'I care'?

virtue theory

theory that assumes that in order to live a good life (achieve a caring response as a professional), one must have good moral character which requires the cultivation of virtues (positive character traits)

character trait

a disposition or a readiness to act in certain ways, e.g., one that is or is not supportive of a high ethical standard

moral character

assemblage of traits that are supportive of a high ethical standard that are continuously put on display and morally define a person

principles

general action guides specifying that some type of action is prohibited, required, or permitted in certain circumstancesBook's def: general moral guidelines in the search for a course of action that will result in an outcome consistent with a caring response

principle-based approach

ethical approach that holds that some general moral norms or action guides are central in moral reasoning

nonmaleficence

Primum non nocere ("First, do no harm.")

beneficence

acting to benefit another

autonomy and self-determination

the capacity to act on your decisions freely and independently

fidelity

faithfulness to one's commitments

veracity

habitual truthfulness

paternalism

a policy or practice of treating or governing people in a fatherly manner, especially by providing for their needs without giving them rights or responsibilities

justice

the principle of being fair and reasonable

deontology

the study of the nature of duty and obligation

deontologic theories

ethical theory which maintains that in order to do what is good (achieve a caring response) one must determine and act upon one's duties

teleology

consequence-oriented theory

absolute duties

duties that are binding under all circumstances; they can never give way to another compelling duty or right

prima facie duties

duties that allow you to make choices among conflicting principles

conditional duties

a commitment that comes into being only after certain conditions are met

teleologic theories

ethical theories which maintains that in order to do what is good (achieve a caring response) one must place the focus on the ends brought about by and the consequences of actions

utilitarianism

teleologic theory that maintains that an act is right if it helps to bring about the best balance of benefits over burdens, in other words, the best "utility" or consequences overall

rule utilitarian

hybrid of deontologic and utilitarian approaches; maintains that you will always being about more good consequences by following certain "rules" or duties